SA needs a new strategy to drive growth and jobs

MENU  DATA  SIGN IN SUBSCRIBE   Create account Free   Newsletters Free   Insider Gold R70pm   Insider Pro Advisors   Support journalism PODCASTS LISTEN     MoneywebNOW   Moneyweb@Midday   RSG Geldsake   SAfm Market Update   All podcasts Click an ADVISOR   Advisor profiles   Advisor views   Reader questions   Submit a question   Sign up MOBILE Tools: Daily indicators Sens Comparison Tool Watchlist   Unit Trusts: Click a Unit Trust Unit Trust stats Unit Trust holdings ETFs & ETNs Asset Managers ALL DATA TOOLS Shares: Click a Company Company stats Winners & losers 52-week highs/lows Top by value/volume Top 40 Companies Consensus forecasts JSE sectors Business calendar Director dealings Dividend watch Dividend History Company contacts Annual Reports Heatmap JSE Indices Value Move % World Indices Value 1 day 7 day Currencies Value Move % Commodities Value Move % 2 SHARES Facebook Twitter LinkedIn WhatsApp Email Print Share this article × 2 Shares Facebook Twitter LinkedIn WhatsApp Email Print SA needs a new strategy to drive growth and jobs Join our free mailing list for top business news. × Next article Farming alongside leopards: Can coexistence work? × Moneyweb@Midday   SA needs a new strategy to drive growth and jobs ‘We have to make sure that we encourage entrepreneurship, we encourage individuals and small companies to innovate, and we also find partnerships,’ says Alan Hirsch, head of the Migration Governance Reform in Africa programme, New South Institute. Jeremy Maggs · 16 Oct 2026, 17:39  You can also listen to this podcast on iono.fm here. JEREMY MAGGS: South Africa’s unemployment crisis has become so entrenched that we risk accepting it as a permanent feature of our economy. Now listen to this figure, more than 12 million South Africans now without work when discouraged job seekers are included, while roughly two-thirds of the population live in varying degrees of poverty. Now the New South Institute is launching a new series, it’s called Can We Build Shared Prosperity in South Africa? It examines, as I understand it, the difficult choices needed to reverse this trajectory. Alan Hirsch, who heads the institute’s Migration Governance Reform in Africa programme, is leading the initiative. Alan, welcome to you. Is the country’s unemployment crisis then fundamentally a failure of policy, or have we simply built an economy that was never designed to absorb the majority of its people? ALAN HIRSCH: Well, it’s the combination of two, I guess. But it’s also, I think, a result of just poor governance, not necessarily that the policies are bad, but the levels of corruption, the levels of political instability and a set of rules, perhaps, that are more suited to a first-world economy than a developing economy. We haven’t allowed people to take advantage of opportunities to create jobs, create businesses. Read: Unemployment rate jumps to four-year high of 33.6% Unlocking economic puzzles with academic insight ADVERTISEMENT CONTINUE READING BELOW JEREMY MAGGS: I wonder if that poor governance then, that you refer to, has simply become too entrenched within the political economy of South Africa, and it’s going to be very difficult to move the needle. ALAN HIRSCH: Well, I think with the government of national unity (GNU), with the Madlanga Commission… I was just reading about the Home Affairs Department, has already prosecuted 98 people for corruption. I think there is a shift, how quickly that shift will happen and how effectively it will happen across the entire economy is another matter, because obviously there’s a lot of problems at the municipal level. But for the national government, things seem to be improving and, and perhaps in some of the provincial governments. JEREMY MAGGS: Let’s focus on policymaking itself, though. You’ve been involved in economic policymaking for decades. If you look back, Alan, where did we perhaps make the most consequential wrong turn? Was there anything that policymakers failed to anticipate? ALAN HIRSCH: Well, we kind of anticipated the possibility of the global financial crisis. But I don’t think that after the global financial crisis, we realised how long the effects would be and how long it would take for us to get going again. So we spent a lot of money in the period after 2008, hoping that this is a relatively short-term turnaround. Got into debt, got into trouble, and then obviously we had issues with corruption in the [Jacob] Zuma government with the more or less collapse of many of our infrastructural services, which compounded those fiscal problems. Then when we were trying to recover, we had to bail out Transnet, we had to bail out Eskom. We had Covid and a series of setbacks that made things very difficult. But I think the critical mistakes were made in the period after the global financial crisis and with the Zuma government. JEREMY MAGGS: We have though pursued fiscal discipline, inflation targeting, industrial policy, social protection. And yet, as I referenced in my introduction, mass unemployment does persist. Do you think, Alan, the problem is with the individual policies or the absence of a coherent development strategy? And we can then get on to your series about shared prosperity stemming from that. ALAN HIRSCH: I think that the macroeconomic policies are bearing fruit. I think we now have a stable currency. We now have increasing confidence in South Africa. So I think we now have an opportunity to actually move into a new gear. We also have the relative success of the early phases of Operation Vulindlela with Eskom in particular, with Transnet to some extent, and in some of its other interventions. I think we really are ready to look forward and to see what the possibilities are. ADVERTISEMENT: CONTINUE READING BELOW JEREMY MAGGS: As we look forward, your new series then asks whether we can build shared prosperity. So, Alan Hirsch, what are you hoping to challenge in the prevailing economic consensus? What would constitute a meaningful outcome from this work? ALAN HIRSCH: Well, I think you’re right to say that there isn’t a very clear overall view of where growth and jobs are going to come from. I think we’ve been operating in a kind of stabilisation mode – let’s get things sorted again. Now we have to think about how we are going to grow and create jobs effectively. The first step has to be to accelerate formal sector growth, and I think that there are steps being taken in this direction, but we can go a lot further. The second step, although they can be taken in parallel, is to significantly improve the environment for what is now called the informal sector, for very small businesses in townships, in cities, even in the rural areas where there are opportunities for businesses to grow, which are being restricted at the moment in various ways. The third element we think is going to be how do we take advantage of the opportunities posed by the current revolution in information and communication technologies to empower, especially the middle segment of our economy, the precarious small businesses, sole entrepreneurs, people who have the possibility of growing but don’t have the tools to do it. We think that if we put those three strategies together, we can focus on both growth and jobs. Without growth, jobs are going to be really hard. But if growth happens, we have to focus on jobs as well, because just growth alone isn’t going to create enough jobs. JEREMY MAGGS: To your last point, you argue for developing a productive middle. Is there any institutional financial market failure that has prevented these smaller enterprises from growing into businesses that employ significant numbers of people? Because my sense is, if you get that part of the equation right, it will certainly exponentially improve growth. ADVERTISEMENT: CONTINUE READING BELOW ALAN HIRSCH: Yeah, I think there’s a lot more we can do. I think we’re beginning to see what’s possible with companies like Yoco, iKhokha, which was bought by Nedbank and Capitec, all offering portable payment systems, which makes a huge difference to the possibilities for those firms. You have things like the Takealot Personal Shoppers programme in the townships, where individuals act as sort of relays for a broader community in terms of shopping… I think that there are solutions emerging. I think that we as South Africans are very imaginative. I think Yoco was an example of a fantastic innovation that was critically important and now has led to other developments. So I think, yes, there have been gaps, but those gaps can be filled. JEREMY MAGGS: And just finally, on a broader canvas maybe, given our fiscal constraints and also limited or challenged state capacity, do we need perhaps a few tightly focused interventions over another national growth plan? ALAN HIRSCH: Well, I think we do need to be focused quite narrowly. But I do think also in the context of a state which is not very strong, we have to make sure that we encourage entrepreneurship, we encourage individuals and small companies to innovate, and we also find partnerships. We have to we have to build much more trust and partnerships between the private sector and the state in order to achieve those objectives. JEREMY MAGGS: Alan Hirsch, thank you very much indeed, from the New South Institute, heading the institute’s Migration Governance Reform in Africa programme. Appreciate your time. Google See more of Moneyweb Google News Follow our coverage Newsletters Get news in your inbox Social Media Join the conversation Social media Follow us on our official channels: TAGS: Alan Hirsch |  entrepreneurs |  entrepreneurship |  Eskom |  Ikhokha |  informal sector |  Jeremy Maggs |  job seekers |  Moneyweb@midday |  MoneywebAtMidday |  New South Institute |  Operation Vulindlela |  poor governance |  sa economy |  sa gdp AUTHOR PROFILE Jeremy Maggs   Follow   More articles Jeremy is a media specialist with a career spanning 40 years in television, radio, and print. He is also the host of Moneyweb’s weekly FixSA podcast. COMMENTS   0 You must be signed in to comment. SIGN IN SUBSCRIBE or create a free account. Free users can leave 4 comments per month. Subscribers can leave unlimited comments via our website and app. MORE Moneyweb@Midday Farming alongside leopards: Can coexistence work? 16 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs Dairy farmers squeezed as Lactalis cuts milk prices by 10% 15 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs Xenophobia threatens SA’s African trade ambitions 15 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs Cape Town’s water supply is stable, but for how long? 14 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs Why you’re paying 16.2% more for chicken 14 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs Former UK defence chief on the global power shift investors can’t ignore 13 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs LATEST INDICATORS   USD / ZARGBP / ZAREUR / ZARBTC / USDJSE ALSIGOLDBrent Crude $ More Indicators   ADVISOR VIEWS Gifts from the taxman 16 Oct 2026 / Hendri De Klerk Two funds, one big bet on America 16 Oct 2026 / Werner Gerber Retirement planning is about more than your balance sheet 15 Oct 2026 / Cole Zweistra Choosing a living annuity: The decisions that matter most 15 Oct 2026 / Alex Odendaal The hidden cost of trying to improve your retirement portfolio 14 Oct 2026 / Wouter Fourie Go to Click an Advisor   Editor's Picks Commented Top Read 1State fights to reclaim land used for holiday homes and restaurants2Demand for prosecutions over R3.5bn ‘too-tall trains’3Tanzanian court strikes out R3.2bn case against Motsepe 1A tax system in need of an overhaul   152SA factories crater as China imports stunt revival   123Joburg mayor defends his record, but the numbers don’t lie   10 1 Tanzanian court strikes out R3.2bn case against Motsepe 2 State fights to reclaim land used for holiday homes and restaurants 3 Former Mxit CEO on the mistakes that cost SA a tech giant ADVISOR VIEWS Gifts from the taxman 16 Oct 2026 / Hendri De Klerk Two funds, one big bet on America 16 Oct 2026 / Werner Gerber Retirement planning is about more than your balance sheet 15 Oct 2026 / Cole Zweistra Choosing a living annuity: The decisions that matter most 15 Oct 2026 / Alex Odendaal Go to Click an Advisor   Moneyweb Newsletters * indicates required Email Address * First Name * Last Name Moneyweb newsletters Moneyweb NOW - Morning news Moneyweb Weekly Wrap-up Op RSG Geldsake vanaand (in Afr) On SAFM Market update tonight Moneyweb Events and Webinars Moneyweb Crypto By subscribing, you agree to receive the Moneyweb emails you selected above. You can unsubscribe at any time. View our privacy policy. MORE Moneyweb@Midday Farming alongside leopards: Can coexistence work? 16 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs Dairy farmers squeezed as Lactalis cuts milk prices by 10% 15 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs Xenophobia threatens SA’s African trade ambitions 15 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs Cape Town’s water supply is stable, but for how long? 14 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs Why you’re paying 16.2% more for chicken 14 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs Former UK defence chief on the global power shift investors can’t ignore 13 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs LATEST ARTICLES RSG Geldsake Volledige Program RSG Geldsake met Moneyweb – Vrydag 16 Oktober 2026 16 Oct 2026 / Tinus de Jager   Tinus de Jager – Moneyweb. Aangebied deur Kruger Internasionaal Kenners antwoord luisteraarsvrae Belastingtoegewings: So gebruik jy die stelsel wettig tot jou voordeel LATEST OPINION 30 years after Masterbond, investors are still vulnerable … UPDATE MTBPS 2026: R50bn tax windfall bolsters SA’s upgrade prospects We hate inflation until it raises our house prices SPONSORED Brought to you by Future Forex Moving funds into and out of SA? Here’s how to save time and reduce costs 16 October 2026 James Vigne Villic Wealth (Pty) Ltd ASK AN ADVISOR How can I reduce my tax liability and plan for estate duty? 8 September 2026 Home Latest articles Fast News In depth Absa Retail and Business Banking Bonitas Eduvos Future Forex GIBS LookSee Merchant West Nedbank Agri Nedbank CIB Ninety One OUTsurance Peregrine Capital Platinum Portfolios PSG Wealth Standard Bank Group Stanlib Investing Commodities Equities ESG ETFs Offshore investing Property SME Unit Trusts News South Africa Africa International Budget Companies and Deals Economy Fast News Investigations Industry Markets Marketingweb Mineweb Tech Radio – Listen Live SAFM Market Update RSG Geldsake Podcasts Be a Better Investor The Ballot Sheet The Business of Africa Crypto podcasts Doen jou eie ding How to Make Money Moneyweb@Midday MoneywebNOW Mzansi Business The Property Pod Special Report MyMoney Financial Planning Personal Finance Tax Opinion Columnists Soapbox Tools and data 52-Week Highs/Lows Annual Reports Asset Managers Business Calendar Company Stats Company contact info Comparison Tool Click a Company Consensus forecasts Daily Indicators Directors’ Dealings Dividend History ETFs & ETNs Heatmap JSE Sectors Portfolios/Watchlist Sens Top 40 Companies Top by Value & volume Unit Trust Holdings Unit Trust Stats Unit Trust Search Winners & Losers Moneyweb Crypto Crypto podcasts Bitcoin Ethereum MoneywebTV Executive Exchange Webinars All videos Click an Advisor Advisor Profiles Advisor Views Reader questions Submit a question Sign up – Click an Advisor Enquire – Click an Advisor Subscribe Insider GOLD Insider PRO – Click an Advisor Newsletters Support journalism Moneyweb App Stay updated Login Register Information & FAQ Help About us Contact us Advertise Authors & Presenters Careers Investor relations PAIA Manual Terms of Use (Privacy Policy, Ts & Cs) Cookie Policy Complaints Home News Newsletters Insider subscription Daily indicators Click a company Click an Advisor Radio / Livestream Podcasts About Moneyweb Advertise with us Contact Moneyweb Help Information & FAQ Moneyweb App Privacy Policy / Terms of Use Price and trade data source: JSE Ltd. Statistics calculated by Profile Data. Data is delayed by at least 15 minutes. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use. Copyright © 2026 Moneyweb (Pty) Ltd. All Rights Reserved. Home News Latest News Fast News South Africa Africa AI Budget Companies and Deals Covid-19 Economy Eskom Industry International Investigations Markets Marketingweb Mineweb Tech In depth Absa Retail and Business Banking Bonitas Eduvos Future Forex GIBS LookSee Merchant West Nedbank Agri Nedbank CIB Ninety One Old Mutual Group Communications Otto1890 OUTsurance Peregrine Capital Platinum Portfolios PSG Wealth Standard Bank Group Stanlib Webinars Events View all MyMoney Educational Video Series Financial Planning Personal Finance Retirement #SavingsMonth Tax Investing Commodities Equities ESG ETFs Offshore investing Property SME Unit Trusts Crypto Crypto news Crypto podcasts Bitcoin Ethereum Opinion Columnists Soapbox Desk of the President Podcasts All podcasts Be a Better Investor The Ballot Sheet with Ray Mahlaka The Business of Africa Crypto podcasts Executive Exchange FixSA How to Make Money With … Mandates & Megaphones Moneyweb@Midday MoneywebNOW Mzansi Business The Property Pod Supernatural Stocks Special Report Doen jou eie ding Small Business Conversations Radio Listen live RSG Geldsake SAFM Market Update MoneywebTV Executive Exchange Mzansi Business Click an Advisor Sign up for Click an Advisor All advisor profiles Advisor views Reader questions Submit your question Contact us Tools and data All data tools 52-week highs/lows Asset Managers Annual Reports Business calendar Click a Company Company contacts Company stats Comparison Tool Daily indicators Directors’ dealings Dividend History ETF & ETN search Heatmap JSE sectors Portfolio Tool / Watchlist SENS Top 40 Companies Top by value/volume Unit Trust holdings Unit Trust Search Unit Trust Stats Winners and losers INSIDER SUBSCRIPTION APP NEWSLETTERS PODCASTS RADIO / LISTEN LIVE VIDEOS WEBINARS TRENDING FOLLOW US: SEARCH: Search Search JSE companies: Unit Trusts ETFs/ETNs SENS TRENDING: More Clicks tweaks ClubCard offer to counter Dis-Chem rewards threat 15 Oct 2026  /  Hilton Tarrant   2 A tax system in need of an overhaul 15 Oct 2026  /  Amanda Visser   15 IN DEPTH: Sponsored Brought to you by Future Forex Moving funds into and out of SA? Here’s how to save time and reduce costs Brought to you by Merchant West Quality investing: What separates the winners from the rest SIGN IN: Email Password Stay logged in Forgot password Create a free account, or contact us to assist. Access all our articles Post comments and replies News & Sens email alerts Premium data tools Sens archive and Sens PDFs. SUBSCRIBE NOW You can cancel at any time.

Read the full article at Moneyweb